This whole idea of how we think about things just keeps being such an important idea for me to contemplate. I really do think this is one of the most important things that happens when we go through transformation. I actually think it is something that happens at the front end of transformation. If we stay stuck in old familiar ways of thinking we more than likely will stay stuck in the old familiar patterns of living based on old belief systems ingrained in us by our years of alienation caused by attempting to live independently. What follows here is a post from a short while ago. I felt it was important for myself to read again. The quote from Walter Brueggemann is something I read over and over while going through a dramatic change of thinking last year. I still find it important today to go back periodically to read it again. So.....that is why I have moved it up to the top again. Maybe it will be helpful to someone that stops by here to read whatever crazy things I might be pondering.I had an interesting day of conversations in regards to how we think. Our thinking creates many perceptions and these perceptions become in a sense our reality. If we continue to live like this it becomes irrelevant whether the perceptions are false, they take on a life of their own in our minds and become "true" as far we are concerned.
I have been surrounded recently by a number of people who have allowed suspicions of others to take root in their minds and hearts and the wild growth of these suspicions has just been stunning. So many times, at least in my experience, what is seen as fact or truth about the other so often isn't even close to being true. But the seed has been sown and in too many of us that seed finds fertile soil to take root and the new seedling grows rapidly. As far as relationships go this is just disastrous.
That is one way that our thinking can create many problems for us.
But it was another area of thinking that initiated this post. I guess I would describe it as a way of thinking that never allows an alternative thought....a different perspective on what is possible or even what is reality and truth. This way of thinking that I am sharing today might open up for me a new possibility...a greater freedom...or they could lead me to a place that I never intended. Maybe even some difficulty? Is it worth the risk? Not only do I think so, I think it is necessary for us to grow and avoid finding ourselves in a place like Nicodemus found himself. But Nicodemus had something churning inside his head and heart that led him to go out into the night under the cover over darkness.....against all of his "better" Pharisaical judgement. Try to imagine what he was feeling. Maybe some disorientation? Maybe some sick-to-his-stomach feelings? Maybe some out right paralyzing fear? But he went and took the risk, because he had heard something that had caused some alternative thinking to begin in his head.
If you don't know the story go read it. The religious system and much of it's teaching has so screwed this one up. Well at least how I am seeing it these days. We have used this encounter between Nicodemus and Jesus to create what we call a "Born Again" experience. Sadly, kind of like an event similar to getting your drivers licences, only more important. In doing this, I think we miss the wonder and the tension of what was going on in Nicodemus and what God desires for us all. That encounter seems to me to be more about having the courage to reconsider everything...to let go of all we think we know and start over....to become like a child....in a sense wipe the slate clean. It is living with the ability to think differently over and over again. Not a one time moment of deciding to believe...it is an attitude of living as children live...that is, until adults and this world get a hold of them and turn them into more adults that lose their child like trust in the loving father that is caring for them.
As this happens, they like so many others become suspicious of almost everyone to some degree, and begin to form many illusions in an attempt to bring certainty to a life that offers no certainty. Fear then takes over and a life of protecting ourselves is set in motion and we form hardened positions and ways of thinking that become entrenched in our minds and hearts....at this point alternative thinking becomes almost impossible. We either become ones who "know that we know it all" or so afraid to questioning things because of what we have been told might happen to us if we do. We become stuck.....that is....unless something happens. Nicodemus took a risk and walked out into the scary night to see the one who seemed to speak of something so different than the religion that apparently had left him wondering if there was something more. I think he found what he was looking for that night in the gentle loving company of Jesus, the one that had just pulled the rug out from under him. Jesus took from him that night the "certainty" that had been his former belief system. I bet you that very night and the days to follow, Nicodemus felt wrung out like a rag....yet exhilaratingly alive.
I want to end these thoughts with something from a present day Old Testament Theologian, Walter Brueggemann from his book The Prophetic Imagination.
He speaks of the culture and it's mindset as the royal consciousness.
"We also are children of royal consciousness. All of us, in one way or another, have deep commitments to it. So the first question is: How can we have enough freedom to imagine and articulate a real historical newness in our situation? That is not to ask, as Israel's prophets ever asked, if this freedom is realistic or politically practical or economically viable. To begin with such questions is to concede everything to the royal consciousness even before we begin. We need to ask not whether it is realistic or practical or viable but whether it is imaginable. We need to ask if our consciousness and imagination have been so assaulted and co-opted by the royal consciousness that we have been robbed of the courage or power to think an alternative thought."
Can we risk trusting Jesus, so as to believe in something other than what this world and it's economic, political and religious systems tell us?
"The royal consciousness leads people to despair about the power to move toward new life. It is the task of prophetic imagination and ministry to bring people to engage the promise of newness that is at work in our history with God."
As Nicodemus found out, alternative thinking might feel risky and scary...but in reality, the only thing risky and scary is to remain under the control of the royal consciousness, unable to have an alternative thought.
5 comments:
Yes! Well said... I think this is where the Jews may have failed in their cultural religion. They forgot the "why" and the wonder, and stuck to the "how" and "what" of their faith.
Looking back in Scripture it seems so clear that God intended one thing and His message was only understood by a few who had a difficult time getting His message across as well.
I hope it doesn't sound like I am blaming the Jews for anything! I have nothing but respect for them...but I think their history is a good example of losing the forest for the trees and being headstrong....demanding a kingdom with a King instead of a family with a loving and protective Father.
I know Israel is not where you were headed with this post, but it rang that bell in my head. :)
Hey Kent,
Good stuff. Our ponderings run along tangential lines much of the time :)
I think we so underestimate the power of imagination, in the terms you are speaking about here and also in terms of storytelling etc. We have relegated to something that is "not real therefore non existent". But every child knows that stories may not be real but are nevertheless real (take The Shack, for instance).
The Aborigines of Australia have traditionally viewed the land through "songlines" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Songlines). I learnt about these several years ago and it is just beautiful. It informs the way they treat the land, the depth of knowledge they have about it (ours is very much surface-related, probably a lot of that is to do with guilt. It's why we attach ourselves like limpets to the coastline). But Western reductionist thinking could look at the way they view the world and poo-poo it as not being real ... but in the sense that they view it, it becomes irrelevant whether it's real or not because it's essence is real.
Oh dear. I'm going all Platonic on myself this morning. I'm sounding very postmodern - but I think that above is one of the good things that is beginning to come out of postmodernity.
Sue, I love thinking about things from different angles. We so often seem to live afraid of questioning the accepted "facts" or accepted "truth". History is one of the things people seem so willing to just accept. The ones who win the battles are the ones that get to write the history.....just because they won the battles doesn't necessarily mean they were right.
In a conversation with a client today we got to talking about the Native American Indians. She works with a group called Parents as Teachers and she goes into reservation schools out in the western part of the US. She says it is just aweful. So this is one of the things of our history that not only was wrong when it first happened but we as a nation just continue to ignore how wrong it is that it continues today.
It just seems that the way we humans deny these things and white wash them is a part of our flawed ways of thinking? For the evangelical community here in America to say things like; "We need to return to the ideas of the founding fathers" falls into this also. There was a lot colluding with a wicked way of thinking that was going on at the time this nation was founded that just justified or turned a blind eye to many evils going on.
I wonder today how much we are colluding with our culture or turning a blind eye to the wrongs of our generation? What will our descendants being scratching their heads about wondering how we could have accepted such things and participated in such things?
This is why having the courage and ability to think differently is so important.
Jennifer, if there was direction I was hoping this post would go it would have been in helping us all to not be afraid to think differently.
You went where your thinking happened to take you. That is a good thing. Thanks for sharing it.
Loved it all Kent, thanks. I really liked these thoughts.
Jesus took from him that night the "certainty" that had been his former belief system. I bet you that very night and the days to follow, Nicodemus felt wrung out like a rag....yet exhilaratingly alive.
As Nicodemus found out, alternative thinking might feel risky and scary...but in reality, the only thing risky and scary is to remain under the control of the royal consciousness, unable to have an alternative thought.
Post a Comment